Phish.net- I Ain't Broke But I'm Badly Bent
- I Am A Lonesome Fugitive
- I Am Hydrogen
- I Am Oysterhead
- I Am the Sea
- I Am the Walrus
- I Been Around
- I Been Hoodooed
- I Been to Georgia on a Fast Train
- I Believe
- I Believe to My Soul
- I Can See Clearly Now
- I Can't Quit You Baby
- I Didn't Know
- I Don't Care
- I Don't Know What You Come to Do
- I Don't Mind 'Cause I'm Blind
- I Don't Wanna Play House
- I Done Done It
- I Feel Like Dynamite
- I Found a Reason
- I Get a Kick Out of You
- I Get High
- I Got Loaded
- I Got You (I Feel Good)
- I Just Want To See His Face
- I Kissed a Girl
- I Know a Little
- I Know You Rider
- I Miss My Mind
- I Remember
- I Remember Ray
- I Roll Into Town
- I Saw the Light
- I Shall Be Released
- I Told You So
- I Touch Myself
- I Walk on Guilded Splinters
- I Walk the Line
- I Wanna Be Like You
- I Want To Be a Cowboy's Sweetheart
- I Want to Die Easy
- I Want to Hold Your Hand
- I Want to Take You Higher
- I Washed My Hands in Muddy Water
- I Will
- I Will Set You Free
- I WIll Survive
- I Wish
- I Wish I Could Say
- I'd Like Off
- I'll Come Running
- I'll Never Grow Tired of You
- I'll Wait For You
- I'm a Little Bit Lonesome
- I'm Bad, I'm Nationwide
- I'm Blue, I'm Lonesome
- I'm Deranged
- I'm Going Back to the Old Home
- I'm Gone
- I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles)
- I'm Lost, I'll Never Find the Way
- I'm Movin' On
- I'm One
- I'm So Glad
- I'm So Tired
- I'm the Slime
- I'm Yours
- I've Got a Feeling
- I've Had Enough
- I've Turned Bad
- I’ve Been Loving You Too Long
- Icculus
- ICU
- Idea
- If 6 Was 9
- If I Can't Turn to You
- If I Could
- If I Could Be a Sailor
- If I Don't Be There By Morning
- If I Only Had a Brain
- If I Told You
- If There's Still Ramblin' in the Rambler (Let Him Go)
- If You Ask Me
- If You Need a Fool
- If You're Walking
- Igor
- Iko Iko
- Immigrant Song
- Impressions
- In a Hole
- In a Mellow Tone
- In a Misty Glade
- In a Sentimental Mood
- In a Silent Way
- In an Intensive Care Unit
- In Each Love, Some Pain Must Fall
- In Harmony
- In Memory of Elizabeth Reed
- In Spirals
- In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
- In the Kitchen
- In the Light
- In the Midnight Hour
- In the Mood
- In the Wee Wee Hours
- Ingest
- Insects
- Inside Out
- Instant Karma!
- Intensified
- Into the Mystic
- Invisible
- Invisible
- Irish Jig
- Iron Man
- Is Anybody Goin' to San Antoine?
- Is It In My Head?
- Is There Anybody Here That Love My Jesus?
- Islands in Space
- Isles of Langerhan
- Isolate
- It Ain't No Use
- It Makes No Difference
- It Takes a Lot to Laugh, It Takes a Train to Cry
- It's All Over Now
- It's Ice
- It's in the Air (Konfusion)
- It's My Life
- It's Up to You
- It's Your Thing
- Izabella
- The Illustrated Band
- The Inlaw Josie Wales
- The Israelites