Set 1: Tube Kill Devil Falls Ocelot Lawn Boy Divided Sky Boogie On Reggae Woman Camel Walk Cities Poor Heart 46 Days Susskind Hotel When the Circus Comes Timber (Jerry the Mule) Back on the Train Suzy Greenberg Monkey Man
 Phish debut.
 Introductions of Runaway Jim 5K winners.
 Page on theremin.
Notes: This was the second of the three-show SuperBall IX festival. This gig featured the Phish debuts of Susskind Hotel and Monkey Man. Camel Walk contained a Spanish Moon tease from Mike, Piper contained a Tweezer tease from Page, and Tweezer contained Scents and Subtle Sounds teases by Mike. Runaway Jim included introductions and trophy awards for the winners of the Runaway Jim 5K road race held earlier in the day. The first Secret Language since July 3, 2000 (213 shows) was a Simpsons signal after BOAF. Scents was played with the intro for the first time since August 2, 2003 (146 shows). The Storage Jam and Sleeping Monkey featured Page on theremin for the first time since August 11, 1997 (394 shows).